Sometimes, things don’t go according to plan. By Saturday morning, as we headed out to the airport, Monica and I knew we weren’t going to our favorite taproom in Santa Clara for some pita points and great beer. By Sunday morning, we learned through a social media post that we could no longer go to our favorite cafe because they were closed for Easter Sunday. That just meant we had to go with Plan B for this weekend. We landed in San Jose roughly around 12 o’clock, just in time for lunch. We drove 30 miles north, away from San Jose, to Fieldwork for some roasted brussels sprouts and tried out the Hail Mary, a Detroit-style pizza topped with beer-braised chicken, cotija, mozzarella, garlic purée, calabrian chili sauce, and honey. Fieldwork was a delicious combination of food and beer and served as a solid second choice. The same was true for our second breakfast option. Cafe Rosalena describes itself as serving world-famous breakfast burritos. These burritos are massive in both length and weight. They pack egg, soyrizo, potato, cheese, and avocado into giant tortillas, and one is easily enough for two people. Again, Cafe Rosalena wasn’t our first choice, but the quality was still there.

I started to get a bad feeling about this match as soon as the MLS availability report came out on Friday afternoon. Listed on the report for San Diego were Alejandro Alvarado, Chris McVey, Amahl Pellegrino, Ian Pilcher, Andres Reyes, Kieran Sargeant, and Pablo Sisniega. We already knew Alvarado and Reyes would miss most of this season. McVey was out due to a red card in the last match. However, I was not expecting Pellegrino and Pilcher to both be out. Pilcher, who has split his time at center back and right back, could have been an option to play with McVey suspended. It made more sense once Mikey Varas talked during his media availability about Osvald Søe starting in place of McVey. San Diego FC didn’t have any other option. The same went for Lewis Morgan, who was available to talk on Thursday and looked as though he was starting the match on Saturday. With Pellegrino out with an injury, the reason Morgan was starting became clear. San Diego FC had to revert to their B plan, and it’s not as strong of an option. Prior to Saturday’s match, Morgan had only played over 60 minutes once, and it was unclear if he could give much more than that for this match. Meanwhile, Søe had only started one other match, and that was against FC Dallas where he did not look great. San Diego’s depth was being tested, and beyond the starters, the options on the bench did not look any better.

From the jump, the two players in the lineup due to injury and suspension cost San Diego the lead. After a free kick taken by Jeppe Tverskov in the 13th minute, a long kick was sent out to Lewis Morgan. Morgan had trouble controlling the ball and was eventually cornered by two San Jose players. Morgan started to dribble back towards the San Diego goal and sent a pass back to Osvald Søe. The pass was out of Søe’s reach and was intercepted by Preston Judd. Judd passed the ball forward to Niko Tsakiris, who sent the ball between the near post and goalkeeper Duran Ferree for the first goal. It was a great start for San Jose to be up 1-0 and a disaster-class in back-passing for San Diego. There was no reason for Morgan to pass the ball back; he was better off trying to force a throw-in while cornered on the near sideline. Søe did not look ready for the ball to be near him, and once Niko Tsakiris had it, Søe did nothing to try and stop him. Between San Jose’s first and second goal, San Diego had a few chances to equalize through corner kicks and the run of play, but they did not have a single shot on target during this period.
San Jose struck quickly again in the 28th minute after a foul on Ousseni Bouda caused by Osvald Søe. Jamar Ricketts kicked the ball quickly after the restart and sent a pass out to Preston Judd, who was heading downfield. This caught San Diego off guard. What followed was Manu Duah putting his hands on Judd’s shoulders in the penalty area, which caused a foul and awarded San Jose a penalty kick. Judd sold the foul once Duah had his hands on his shoulders and immediately went down. Some could describe that as a dive, but in this match, the referee awarded the kick as the action prevented a scoring opportunity. Once the penalty kick was awarded, there was a VAR check, not for the foul itself, but for a possible red card on Manu Duah. The referee confirmed the check and gave Duah a red card. This was Duah’s second red card of 2026, with the first coming against Toluca at home. For SDFC, this was the second consecutive MLS match with a red card, following Chris McVey’s in the previous match against Real Salt Lake. As a team, San Diego FC has received five red cards in their last five matches. Niko Tsakiris took the penalty and scored for San Jose. Both goals were Tsakiris’s first two of the season, and by this point, the match was essentially over. San Jose had been trying to corner San Diego with two players all night, and with the man advantage, they could continue doing so.
Just for good measure, San Jose added a third goal from Preston Judd’s foot to make the score 3-0 right before halftime. That goal gave Judd his third of the season. For San Diego FC, the first-half stats were not pretty, showing two total shots and only one shot on target. San Diego had five corner kicks but could not do much with them. In the second half, the stats did not improve; San Diego had two shots with zero on target and zero corners. SDFC had no real shot at coming back in this match. The dominance by San Jose really showed in their passes to the final third, where they had 125 total passes compared to San Diego’s 79. San Jose also completed 72% of their final third passes while San Diego had just 64.6% accuracy. Anders Dreyer led the match with 10 passes into the final third, but ideally, Dreyer should be the one receiving those passes to set him up with a shot. Dreyer had five touches in the opposition’s box with just one shot inside the box. Another player outside of Søe and Manu Duah who had a tough night was David Vazquez, who completed 7 out of 12 passes, won one ground duel, committed two fouls, and had one clearance in 40 minutes of play. After Duah received his red card, an attacking player had to be sacrificed, and that was Vazquez, who has shown promise against Liga MX teams but still needs to build consistency in MLS.
On Instagram, Kewlsocr commented on our last post asking what the incoming players have done to replace those who were transferred out. It is a good question and difficult to quantify, as players who arrived since the summer transfer window have seen limited action alongside Amahl Pellegrino. I’m going to use advanced numbers to try to quantify their contributions, despite the small sample size in 2026. In terms of goals added—a stat that quantifies on-ball contributions on attack or defense—only Bryan Zamble (0.18), Amahl Pellegrino (0.54), and Pedro Soma (0.02) have a positive net total. Currently, Osvald Søe is one of the worst players in the league in this metric with a -0.84, which is the ninth-lowest total in the league. All that means is that Søe is currently doing more to hurt the team than to help it. On the offensive side, Pellegrino (0.97), David Vazquez (0.37), and Bryan Zamble (0.12) have the highest expected goals of the group. Pellegrino (1.19), Sargeant (0.33), Soma (0.18), and Lewis Morgan (0.14) have shown value in expected assists. Pellegrino actually has the second-highest expected assists total on the team, trailing only Anders Dreyer (1.42). It is notable that Amahl Pellegrino has played a big part in this attack; Lewis Morgan and Bryan Zamble just need time to learn the system and integrate properly.
| Player | Matches | Minutes Played | Net Goals Added | Expected Goals | Expected Assists |
| Amahl Pellegrino | 5 | 395 | 0.54 | 0.90 | 1.19 |
| Bryan Zamble | 3 | 60 | 0.18 | 0.12 | 0.00 |
| Pedro Soma | 4 | 177 | 0.02 | 0.00 | 0.18 |
| David Vazquez | 5 | 245 | -0.05 | 0.37 | 0.00 |
| Bryce Duke | 1 | 17 | -0.05 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Lewis Morgan | 3 | 109 | -0.09 | 0.07 | 0.14 |
| Kieran Sargeant | 3 | 295 | -0.17 | 0.02 | 0.33 |
| Wilson Eisner | 2 | 98 | -0.29 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Osvald Soe | 3 | 189 | -0.84 | 0.08 | 0.00 |
In the midfield, it all depends on what you want to do tactically, as Pedro Soma and David Vazquez can be decent choices. Still, it would be nice to have one well-rounded midfielder to provide a boost, help send passes to the forwards, and track back to defend. The backfield is probably the most vulnerable area and must avoid injuries and suspensions at all costs. Osvald Søe may just need more time in training and away from the starting XI for a while, but the team may not have any other option but to play him given that Ian Pilcher’s injury status is unknown. Eisner and Sargeant are two young players you might also gamble on playing. There were times last season when San Diego FC fielded the youngest backline in league history, but there was a veteran goalkeeper helping assist those younger players. With McVey out on Saturday, SDFC tried to field a young backline with an even younger goalkeeper, and the lack of leadership and communication was evident. A young backline only works if there’s at least one veteran helping to communicate and ensuring everyone knows their place. On Saturday night in San Jose, the backline simply got shredded. Speaking of San Jose, the last time San Diego played there, when a young member of the backline like Aiden Hrangi had to come out, veteran Franco Negri was the one to get the call. Negri provided an assist in that match to Marcus Ingvartsen, who also came off the bench.
The reality is that a Plan B only works when there is enough quality to back it up. While Monica and I found that Fieldwork and Cafe Rosalena were more than capable of filling the void left by our favorite spots, San Diego FC’s current depth simply isn’t at that level yet. Watching a young backline and goalkeeper struggle with communication makes it clear that leadership isn’t something you can just substitute on the fly. I am holding out hope that once the summer window opens in July, the front office can bring in the reinforcements needed to turn this roster into a more complete unit. Until then, I’ll keep looking for those silver linings in the local taprooms, but I’d much rather see the team find a way to make their own Plan B a winning one on the pitch.


















